Most nanny interviews stay too surface-level to tell you much. A few specific questions reveal far more than general chit-chat.
Ask about a specific past situation, not a general skill
Instead of "are you good with tantrums," ask "tell me about the last time a child you cared for had a meltdown — what did you do." Specific answers are harder to fake than general reassurances.
Ask what they'd do if they made a mistake
How a nanny responds to "what if you accidentally gave the wrong snack, or the child got a small bump while playing" tells you whether they'll be honest with you later, which matters more than avoiding every mistake.
Ask about their own boundaries
A nanny who can tell you what hours or tasks don't work for them is being honest upfront — better than someone who agrees to everything and then can't sustain it.
Watch how they interact with your child in the room
A short trial interaction, even ten minutes of play, tells you more than another twenty minutes of talking to you. Notice whether they follow your child's lead or try to control it.
Don't skip the practical questions
Confirm availability, notice period, comfort with your specific routines, and expectations around pay and leave clearly, in the same conversation — not after you've already decided you like them.