There's no universally "better" childcare option — a nanny, daycare, and creche each solve a different problem well.
A nanny gives you one-on-one attention and flexibility
For infants, for families with irregular hours, or for parents who want care in their own home, a dedicated nanny is usually the closest fit. The tradeoff is cost and finding someone you trust.
Daycare and creche offer socialization and structure
Toddlers and preschoolers often benefit from being around other children their age, and a good daycare has trained staff and a set routine. The tradeoff is less individual attention and fixed hours that may not match a demanding job.
Cost structures are genuinely different
A full-time nanny's cost is mostly salary and is fairly fixed regardless of hours used. Daycare is usually cheaper per child but charges by enrollment, not by the specific hours you need.
Illness policies quietly matter a lot
Daycares typically won't take a sick child, which means you still need a backup plan for those days even if daycare is your primary option. A nanny at home doesn't have this constraint.
Many families use both, at different ages
It's common to start with a nanny for infancy, move to daycare or creche once a toddler benefits from peer interaction, and keep occasional on-demand help for the gaps either option leaves.